Skip Navigation
 

Friday At ICICI

My latest blog

Watch Out For This Property Scam!

Published in Your Money on 10 October 2008

Some savers with Indian bank ICICI were unable to access their accounts on Friday afternoon.

This article was revised on the morning of Saturday, October 11th.

On Friday afternoon, we couldn't access the ICICI.co.uk website at Fool HQ, although ICICI.com was still up and running. We heard other reports of similar problems elsewhere in the UK.

Friday's problems were worrying for UK savers, as they followed a poor day’s trading for the bank. Shares finished 20% down in Mumbai trading, meaning the bank was the worst performer among financial stocks in Asia on the day. The FT reported that the shares fell on concerns about the bank's operations outside India. However, the bank has a strong capital adequacy ratio of 13.4% compared to the regulatory requirement of 9%.

There were reports on Tuesday of Indian depositors with the bank queuing up at branches and ATMs in the cities of Karnatka and Andraha Pradesh and withdrawing their cash.

However, the good news is that we can access the site on Saturday morning.

A spokesperson for ICICI told Fool.co.uk that there had been no problems with ICICI's server on Friday. It was an issue with some, but not all, internet service providers accessing the site. 

The spokesperson stressed that all transactions had been accepted as normal over the telephone, and extra callers in the bank's call centre had been laid on to deal with any extra enquiries. The UK number is 08081 314 151.

Are my savings safe?

Savings with the bank are protected under the Financial Services Compensation Scheme up to £50,000 – and as with Icesave, the Government is likely to step in if there is a problem.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

ar2507 10 Oct 2008, 7:06pm

Tried logging onto the ICICI.com site but it rejected my log on number/and or password. Contacted ICICI by phone and advised that the UK site is down for technical reasons and that is why my log on details don't work! Also they won't work if you have accessed their site via Google - you need to do it directly through your browser! Anyone know why? Advised to try again tomorrow .....getting a bad feeling about this one after being bitten twice by Iceland banks this week - anyone else out there feel the same?

mikegover 10 Oct 2008, 7:29pm

seems the uk website is now working - but I am not a customer and have not therefore tried to login.

chemeng100 10 Oct 2008, 8:02pm

icici have 8 global websites for markets in different countries around the world. only the uk site is down.
hopefully that implies a web site fault, not a problem with the bank itself.

Raasu 10 Oct 2008, 8:25pm

Seriously I'd advise anyone with money in ICICI to withdraw all your funds immediately if you can.

davidw53 10 Oct 2008, 8:37pm

This is scaremongering as you can also call them by phone on a freefone number, which they answered recently very quickly.

The web site is quite often a bit slow (I've used it for more than 5 years), but this in itself will cause some to panic because of global fears.

Shuggster 10 Oct 2008, 9:08pm

Guys calm down.
Do not panic.
A technical difficulty is usual is ICICI, I can remember 5 distinct events within the last year when this has happened. They have brought it back up, there was also a high mess up with their servers where interest was paid as 2 part one month. And finally earlier this year a bug was found over a weekend and was fixed by Monday.
Yes, their share price fell almost 20% but they are still very solvent and not facing a liquidity crisis as some bloggers believe.
Raasu stop scaremongering!
This is almost a crime with the credit crunch and everything that is going on.
May I also remind you that we are dealing with an Indian bank here not a greedy Western bank. Have you ever heard of an Indian bank go bust?
Finally ICICI UK is almost a UK bank and deposits guaranteed by the FSCA in the UK. Rest well and have a good weekend if you have under 50,000 as it will be returned back to you and you need the rest as next will also be as interesting.
Can someone supply me with a CDS for ICICI, the last check by me showed it around 560.

Shuggster 10 Oct 2008, 9:13pm

Its BACK UP guys.

Well done ICICI.

martint123 10 Oct 2008, 9:34pm

Yup, managed to log in and print off my statements.

Sadly I'm locked in until the end of Feb next year ;(

soulsaver1 10 Oct 2008, 11:01pm

Here is a useful bit of info to look out for, sort of thing Martin Lewis (huh!) and Fool should high light 'cos it can be easily over looked:
If you have a stocks & shares isa and you were prudent or lucky enough to have sold all or some of yr equities and the proceeds (cash) is held in reserve (still in the Isa)by your provider then it will be ring fenced in YOUR NAME in whichever bank the provider uses - Cofunds/Chartwell for example use RBS. This WILL count towards your FSCS limit, so if you've got other funds with that bank you could be exposed.

vishalkhera 10 Oct 2008, 11:26pm

Guys, ICICI BANK HAS STOPPED HONORING ONLINE REQUESTS FOR PREMATURE CLOSURE OF FIXED DEPOSITS.

I am a domestic (indian) customer and have been trying this online since 10th morning; request is not being entertained stating "overload" as a reason. I wrote to the Account manager using infinity (icici online), and this is the first time in the last 10 years that I received a reply from the Account manager to call up "helpline" to raise this request. Similar requests have been entertained by the Account manager umpteen numbers of times before.

I tried to call up helpline, and they started explaining me how to do the same using infinity. I said I have tried that, and they said that I need to do it that way only. IT IS VERY CLEAR...NO MATTER HOW MUCH IS EXPLAINED BY OUR RESPECTED INDIAN FINANCE MINISTER OR IN SPECIAL PRESS CONFERENCES BY ICICI CORRESPONDENTS...THESE GUYS ARE IN SOUP AND OUR MONEY IS NOT SECURE.

God!!! Help us please

mamom01 11 Oct 2008, 8:34am

A Indian bank went burst about 30 years ago, and then there was no help at all for depositors, many small business suffered twice,lost their money in current account but still had to pay off business loans to liquidators! Then name was similar to Icici as well.

mamom01 11 Oct 2008, 9:11am

BCCI (Bank of Credit and Commerce International, nicknamed by some the Bank of Cocaine and Criminals International), which collapsed in 1991 owing more than pounds 10bn to creditors.
Not quite 30 years ago,only 17 years, but in that short time it has been forgotten, so I believe the story will happen all over again, that's is, the stock market and banks will forget today's lessons. Greed will again drive risky dealing to even giddier heights.

Luniversal 11 Oct 2008, 9:34am

"Cecily, you will read your political economy in my absence. The chapter on the fall of the rupee you may omit. It is somewhat too sensational..."

-- Miss Prism in The Importance of Being Earnest, Oscar Wilde

ArtemisFowl 11 Oct 2008, 9:35am

ICICI have a credit rating of BBB- which is one grade above junk level; they are not paying 7.2% because they are generous, it's just to offset the risk you might loose your capital. Of course there is the HM Govt guarantee. I don't know what admin co-operation is required of an insolvent bank with FSCS before they make a refund, lots I imagine, especially if on-line accounts are to be transferred. I do know from my experience that FSCS seems snowed under by general enquiries never mind any real work. And I also know from experience (6yrs with ICICI in India and uk) that ICICI's admin is - well - Indian.

I wouldn't bank on any rescue going smoothly or quickly - and during that time there is likely to be loads of hassle, mistakes and lost interest.

sov15ski 11 Oct 2008, 9:58am

Having rang ICICI two days running, both yesterday and the day before, I can confirm that the site was running extremely slowly, and I was told by two seperate banking officers that technicians were working to rectify the fault. I would appear that they had no luck at doing this with it still running, and were forced to shut it down to find the problem.
There is absolutely no panic, as can recall previous iccindence of this slow running fault.
I find ICICI an excellent bank, and am fully confident in the security of my savings.
Thank you India for a great savings institution
I have a joint account with them, with near the guaranteed maximum, and i sleep soundly at night.

Mr Woodward

marty680 11 Oct 2008, 9:59am

I fail to see how any intelligent person thinks it is an option to take funds (up to the compensation limit)out of a financial institution and not earn an adequate return.
The Iceland Banks are were not directly covered by the UK scheme, but ICICI is.
All the online websites have some problems at some time, it appears everyone is paranoid at the moment.
Semsible investing means placing your funds with a financial institution (up to the compensation limit) where you can get the best return. This is especially true when the stock market is not worth the risks as is the case as at present. CASH IS KING bur you still need to get an adequate return.

SusanH67 11 Oct 2008, 10:01am

I have arranged to transfer the money from my Hisave account because I need it soon (next few months) for a new kitchen. I have left my 2 fixed term accounts, figuring that if the bank does go bust I will get the money back from the FSA. I have concerns though that the only record I have of my accounts is my accout numbers and a print-out from the screen last night.

LastChip 11 Oct 2008, 10:16am

Chill out everyone!

I've got money in icici, but am not in the least bit worried - it's intentionally below £50,000.

Before I invested there, I carried out due diligence and as far as I'm aware, it's fully covered by the financial compensation scheme. So if there is genuinely a concern (and I'm not convinced there is), the FCS will pay out.

This sort of article and the comments by some contributors does nothing to calm the situation.

If there is a factual problem, then fine, lets all hear about it. But pure conjecture at this point in time, is worthless and down right damaging.

rollseyesnsighs 11 Oct 2008, 10:31am

I attempted to withdraw some of my savings from ICICI on Monday evening. Nothing had arrived in my linked account yesterday (Friday) when I received an email that read:

"Your recent request for funds transfer has been processed in line with your instructions.

You should receive the funds shortly. Regrettably, however, there will be a delay of one day in the funds reaching your account. As a goodwill gesture we will therefore credit your account with a payment of £50. We thank you for your understanding."

I will be most intrigued and delighted if this credit appears in my account!

MonsterMixer 11 Oct 2008, 10:44am

Indian soverign debt was only upgraded from junk last year, to BBB- by the major debt rating agencies.

It's worth remembering that India is an extrememly poor country, with GDP/capita of $942 (source - IMF 2007), which is lower than Nigeria, for example.

ICICI itself has risk in its credit derivatives holdings, and has a large CDS holding (http://sify.com/finance/fullstory.php?id=14617894).

Its own CDS rating has spiked to 900 basis points. (source:http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=aPAn3CZ_qBvc), and personally I think it's toast.

MrRee007 11 Oct 2008, 12:09pm

I am an investor in ICICI as I am/was in Icesave and Kaupthing Edge!

With just hours to spare I got my cash out of Icesave and then also out of Kaupthing Edge - with the exception of my ISA in Icesave (wanting to maintain its Tax status I was in the process of that transfer to NatWest when it went tits-up) ... I consider myself very lucky to have pulled most of my money when I did (despite everyone sying it was fine and I shouldn't panic!).

I have no intention of spending sleepless nights as I did last week, so I shall be acting on my ICICI Account immediately - when you have looked at the very real chance that your entire lifes savings will be wiped out, you act very cautiously indeed.

I admire tha cavalier approach by some above - I really hope that you do not feel as I did last week when my Icelandic Banks went with my money, it is not a nice place to be.

Imcke 11 Oct 2008, 12:12pm

The USA GB and all are in debt, credit agency ratings are rubbish thats why we are in this mess.
credit default swaps beting on a bank going bust special investment vehicals. What the hell is going on. Panic all withdraw funds. the only way banks will be able to work is if all deposits loans are on fixed terms. mortage tie whith high penlty for early switch. or no change at all 25year fix term. The bank makes money facilitating lending your money to earn you intrest. And takes a profit for doing it simple or it used to be.

pdetent 11 Oct 2008, 1:22pm

Have just accessed site with no problem. I needed some cash so I have transfered a sum out - will be interesting to see if it hits my linked account in the normal time scale

davidksa99 11 Oct 2008, 1:45pm

It is my belief that it panic spread by a few that cause the collapse and end up making problems for the many. I have money with ICICI and plan on getting more in and into a bond as quickly as possible. I think that global interest rates will fall shortly therefore ICICI will reduce rates as well. My money is protected (I have well under 50k)I do not consider myself cavalier as one suggested. My mother has life savings money with Icesave,she has no regrets she knows she will get her money.

Stop spreading panic! If you have less than 50k enjoy a good rate of interest and review the situation as things develop.

Kitxp123 11 Oct 2008, 3:28pm

I have savings with IceSave(ISA), Kaupthing Edge UK(Now ING) and ICICI.
I have full faith in Gordon Brown to not let my money dissapear.
He saved my Kaupthing savings by facilitating a purchase agreement from ING.
He has guarenteed 100% of my savings from IceSave regardless of the FSCS limit.
He has promised to maintain my IceSave ISA's tax free status.

IF (and that is a big IF as I don't beleive it will) ICICI do go down then I'm sure Gordon Brown will act in the best interest of his people.
I will not be moving my money from ICICI HiSave account despite it being nearly £3k over the FSCS limit.

When we have one of the greatest economists of our time now as our Prime Minister why is there a need to worry?

Enjoy the rest of the weekend.

tedphill 11 Oct 2008, 4:26pm

Am I the lucky one by not having thousands to put away? What little I know makes me think that part of the financial problem is thousands of people trying to get cash out of banks. Think. Banks don't have that amount of money available. They rely on money/cash coming in, not going out. Look what happenend to Northern Rock when most customers wanted their cash. Think. It ain't there.
This nasty problem should make everyone more careful and read the small print in future.

locum 11 Oct 2008, 9:59pm

I have always found ICICI excellent to deal with- I have nowhere near £50K & my money goes in & out like a yo-yo! I made a withdrawal on Wed & I too had an e-mail yesterday apologising for a 1 day delay & stating £50 would be paid into my account-so I'll check again on Mon.
I also had some savings in Kaupthing but i'm hanging in there- panic withdrawals just make things worse.
I saved for my retirement all my working life,-my pension fund may have taken a knock just now but it will build up again,although it may take a while.
Maybe if we weren't all so greedy(well we DID hunt out & invest in the highest interest,instant access,non-British accounts!) we wouldn't be in this situation today-but then again we have to augment the paltry state pensions somehow since we were stupid enough to have some savings & hence can't get rent,heating etc,etc paid by the government.

MonsterMixer 12 Oct 2008, 4:19am

I don't think shopping around to find the best rate of interest on a bank account is greedy. If the account was so risky, they shouldn't have been allowed to join the FSCS - that's the government's decision.

I do, however, think keeping more than the FSCS maximum in a risky account is irresponsible, and shouldn't be compensated by the tax-payer.

There is clear moral-hazard here. It's clear that icici are at major risk of default, and think government compensation is skewing rational decision making.

leesielover 12 Oct 2008, 11:08am

Just logged on now - much quicker than last week. Transferred a bit out.

Transferred some out last week and it was fine - 3 days as per any BACS transfer. The bulk of mine is a term deposit that I'll leave there until next year. Like everyone here, obviously I'm a bit uneasy as I've been stung buy Icesave, but I'm in for less than £50k and this is (unlike Icesave which had this "Passport" agreement) FULLY covered by the FSCS.

If you're feeling uneasy, have a look at the FSA website and you'll see that ICICI is registered. Apart from being owned by Indians, it's pretty much a uk bank.

So - your exposure beyond ICICI is not to India, but to the UK FSCS. That's something I'm happy to sleep with.

wally144 12 Oct 2008, 1:52pm

Enjoyed the remarks that Kitxp123 made about Gordon Brown.
Where has he been for the last 12 years? As chancellor he spent more money than the government had, increasing taxpayers indebtedness, and now he is continuing this folly in spades.
It may sound callous, but it is about time politicians stopped messing with OUR money, and let the economy sort itself out. Life will be very tough for a while, but we will come out of it stronger, albeit poorer, and I hope, wiser.

Dylkes 12 Oct 2008, 10:10pm

How on Earth do I do it? I'm but a mere NHS secretary in this world, yet EVERYTHING I have predicted about the current economic meltdown has happened. Now, thisismoney.co.uk has withdrawn ICICI Bank from its 'best savings buys' list on account of its poor Fitch rating (BBB-). Had we taken similar notice when they withdrew Kaupthing and Landsbanki, many would not have had such a nerve racking week. Okay, so my savings with ICICI are guaranteed up to £50K, but do you REALLY want to chance things at the moment? If ICICI do go to the great cruncher in the sky who will take over the accounts? ING-Direct again? Also, FBN (Firstsave) have slaughtered their interest rates from 6 to 4.5%. I'm not hopefully, putting gloom and doom where its unwelcome, but facts are facts. In support of ICICI, they are a very responsible Bank who have not been greedy, stupid in their lending practices or, unlike the Western Banks, influenced by the fact that if the US do it, then so should we. I would say this to ICICI Bank - For the sake of financial integrity, issue a statement to your customers NOW!

corbindallas68 13 Oct 2008, 9:50am

I do not think it is scare mongering to suggest anyone with more than 50k in a ICICI account pulls it out asap, there is no assurance that like other banks Gordon Brown will cover all saving's 100% and I don't see why anyone over the FSA limit would in their right mind take a chance to see if this is so.I as a KE customer was/felt reassurred by their website telling me how solid they were in these difficult times, the very next day my account was frozen and then they were transferred to the ING. So do not believe because you got through to their call center and they tell you everything is fine, hey let's face facts they are not going to say we are going under!! One thing that I have read above which sounds a little more alarming is the £50 compensation for transaction problems, not the norm sounds a bit desperate to me!

Jee50 13 Oct 2008, 11:03am

Four transfers which I scheduled on Tues 7th were processed on 9th - I, too got the apology email. The total amount arrived in my HSBC account this morning as I was advised by phone that it would. Why they had a day's delay is not known but they seem to be back on course now. I await a second transfer processed on Sat - we're buying a house(unfortunately we have to move at this time) so the first transfers were necessry not a panic measure.

itrustnoone 13 Oct 2008, 11:14am

Sorry to cast a shadow over the week ahead, but even though I'm the eternal optimist, I fear the worst - all the warning signs are there as were with Kaupthing. It took ages to log on on Friday and today I can't log on to ICICI at all.
My money's on term deposit so there's nothing I can do except wait and hope for the best.

annief41 13 Oct 2008, 12:01pm

I've just spent about an hour trying to access the website - it's insanely slow this morning - but I did get there eventually and I appear to have been able to transfer some money.
Good luck all.

Jee50 13 Oct 2008, 12:16pm

Site is running very slowly but it is working and you can make transfers. Icici shares are up 20% on the Indian markets this morning, and there are rumours of a concerted campaign by text to discredit it which has been reported. I've taken my money outnow because I need it, but the site has always been slow and they have made mistakes which I was compensated for with both deposits and withdrawls. Still waiting for money from KE though...

ajooba 13 Oct 2008, 12:19pm

Agree with Dylkes. ICICI should issue a Bold statement in Big Font on their main page indicating their balance sheet / asset strength.

As Gordon Brown said, confidence is the biggest asset. If all depositors think ICICI will fail and pull out everything, it will become a self fulfilling prophecy.

Part of the problem is that in spite of the FSA protection for less than £50,000, the amount is not paid out rightaway - there is a potential 3 month wait. This causes people to want to pull out, further undermining confidence. In America, if a bank fails, the FDIC pays the protected amount within a week. I know it is fashionable to criticize America in this part of the world, but this is one thing the U.S has got right. They were used to banks failing and so they have put in a system in place. I am saying this as someone who lost money in an American bank last year. I was stupid and had more than the FDIC insured limit ($100,000) last year and the bank went belly-up. The $100,000 was paid in a week. No delay. There was no panic with depositors having to queue up. For the rest of the amount, they had to sell the bank's assets and I got 85% of the uninsured money (over the limit) back within the last year. I have no one to blame but myself for having more than the FDIC limit.

bsingh20 13 Oct 2008, 12:48pm

Hi,

Shares in ICICI went up about 17% this morning on the Bombay Stock Exchange.

A good site for info on the indian market is www.livemint.com.

elainecarlin 15 Oct 2008, 10:58am

Today I tried login on to ICICI bank but I couldn't, called the call centre, but they couldn't action my request to transfer my money, said there was a technical fault and would be OK in a few hours. Not a good sign. Will try again later.

Jee50 15 Oct 2008, 11:52am

All the transfers I asked for have now been made to my linked account - Sat and Mon's came this morning in normal timescale. Their (Icici's)website is often unreliable, we wouldn't be worrying in normal circumstances. Couldn't get into HSBC this morning for about half an hour and spent ages trying to speak to Abbey on Monday, I don't think either of them are at risk. Shall be glad when KE/Ing is resolved though.

elainecarlin 15 Oct 2008, 1:39pm

True to there word, I eventually managed to log on to my account at 1.30pm today, running very very sloooowly, but anyhow managed my transfer request. Fingers crossed that all turns out well.

Jee50 15 Oct 2008, 8:50pm

Just checked my account - £50 complimentary payment has been credited.

Noodleums 22 Oct 2008, 3:53pm

I have been trying for the past three days (from this Monday, 20th October) to transfer a small sum from my ICICI account to another nominated account. Every day so far has been unsuccessful with the same error message coming up each time - technical error, please try another time.

Is anyone else getting this problem?

LateDeveloper 22 Oct 2008, 4:01pm

This is the type of knee jerk response that causes banks to collapse, don't we have enough with irresponsible reporters screaming banking collapse, without having everyone else running around like sheep, following their lead.

Headless chickens would be another terminology applicable in this case too.

pureedfruit 23 Oct 2008, 12:00pm

The reason most of us put our money into ICICI was that it was paying amongst the best rates, and appeared to be reasonably safe. However it is no longer among the best rates, and because how seemingly safe it is, is determined by the banking professionals based on the CDS of its parent company, it is now down at the bottom of the table published by the Fool in its recent "Good, the Bad & the Ugly" email. So many non panicking Fools will be quite calmly and sensibly reviewing their savings and deciding where best to place them.

Regarding this slow on-line access problem, there is an alternative. Fools may or not be aware that if you have not accessed your ICICI account for 6 months your access is automatically disabled. This happned to me so I phoned up. I was offered the option of authorising the transfer to my linked account over the phone, which I did following the ineviatable barage of security questions. Two alternatives - a free BACS transfer taking 3-4 working days, or a £20 CHAPS transfer ostensibly taking 24 hours. I say ostensibly because the confirming email now advises me that it will be processed in 2 working days, which Fools may wish to keep in mind if they may want their money in a hurry.

IanJohnson100 24 Oct 2008, 8:31pm

Had 69k in a theoretically JOINT accoint (which still listed solely under my name)

Over last week have dropped balance to 50k as a precaution - all transfers were on time - agree terrible website, but it does the job.

I am happy to leave at this level - i don't want to contribute to the problem

Join the conversation

Instructions

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: <b>bold</b>, <i>quoted text</i>. All other tags will be removed from your post.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.