Skip Navigation
 

Bail Me Out Please Mr Bush

<%=_author %>

By

Bruce Jackson

From the Fool blog

Local Police Station Is Useless!

Published in Your Money on 6 October 2008

The great US bail-out has passed, yet the pain continues. We are in recession now, and no amount of dollars, euros and pounds is going to stop it. Yet there is hope. Growth always follows recession.

Do home owners with mortgages feel bailed out? No.

Do home owners with no mortgages feel bailed out? No.

Do stock market investors feel bailed out? No.

Do Wall Street and City workers feel bailed out? No.

Does your job feel safer today than it did last week? No.

So who was actually bailed out by the US Government’s US$700 billion economic rescue package, passed by Congress on Friday?

In theory, we’re all bailed out, except we don’t know it or feel it yet.

Think back to the beginning of last week. Share prices were in freefall. Banks across the globe were in serious trouble, including our own HBOS (LSE: HBOS). Savers were seriously considering pulling their money out of banks and putting it under the mattress.

You Know It’s Bad When…

When it gets to that level of fear and panic, you know something bad is happening.

When you get people like 82 year-old former US Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan saying “This is a once in a half century, probably once in a century type of event”, you know something bad is happening.

When you get 78 year-old master investor Warren Buffett saying “…we were at the brink of something that would have made anything that's happened in financial history look pale”, you know something bad is happening.

This is not a bail out. US politicians of both parties, fearing for their own jobs at the forthcoming election, have stopped calling it a bail out.

It’s an economic rescue plan. It’s a TARP – Troubled Asset Relief Program.

As an aside, is it just me, but when I see TARP, I immediately think of TARDIS, the time machine and spacecraft in Doctor Who which can transport its occupants to any point in time and space?

Perhaps I will ask George Bush if he could transport my share portfolio back in time to about a year ago – then I’d truly feel bailed out!

It’s A Bail Out, But We Just Won’t See It

Back in the real world, the economic rescue plan will save us from the banking abyss, the place in hell where your money, your investments, your pension and your insurance policies, are not safe in any financial institution.

But, as we are seeing, it won’t bail us out.

It won’t necessarily stop share prices falling further, as witnessed by Friday’s more than 150 point fall in the Dow Jones Industrial Average, after Congress passed the bill.

It won’t necessarily mean house prices stop falling further – the Nationwide have just said UK house prices have fallen for an 11th consecutive month, dropping by 1.7% in September. Nationwide said the pace of house price falls had stabilised, but warned the next year or two would be "difficult".

It won’t necessarily stop the distress in some over-leveraged banks, as witnessed by the recent part-nationalisation of our own Bradford and Bingley (LSE: BB.) and the rescue of European banks like Benelux’s Fortis and Germany’s Hypo Real Estate.

It’s A Recession, Of Course

It definitely won’t stop a global recession.

Remember, the root cause of this financial crisis is house prices. People need a place to live. Many people prefer to own their own home, rather than rent.

Over the past few years, home ownership suddenly became more accessible…

  • Low interest rates made the home owning dream more affordable.
  • The willingness of banks to lend people large amounts of money relative to their salaries made the home owning dream possible.
  • Some banks were willing to lend people 100% or even more(!!) of the purchase price of the house, making the home owning dream possible.

In that sort of environment, inevitably the prices of house prices went up. As that happened, people became afraid they’d miss out on ever owning their own home. TV programmes showed how ordinary people could become property developers as a second job. The result – house prices went even higher.

But low interest rates don’t last forever. Large mortgages still have to be repaid. Banks can and do tighten their lending procedures. House prices can go down as well as up.

Where To From Here?

So where do we go from here? We are in recession. It may last for 1 year. It may last for 2 years. It could even last for longer. Global economies have been built of debt for many years now. Sales of discretionary items like plasma TVs, new cars, iPods, stereo systems and the like will slump.

But we’ve known that for a while now.

As far as the stock market, I don’t know if we’ve reached the bottom. From time to time we will see huge rallies, amongst more panic selling.

My strategy is threefold…

1. Sit tight on my quality holdings – companies that operate in attractive industries, have high profit margins and little or preferably no debt.

2. Continue to dump any company that is more speculative, including those in poor industries with low profit margins.

3. Use the proceeds from sales plus adding new money into my favourite holdings over the next few weeks.

It’s not all doom and gloom. Economies and markets do recover. As far as I know, there has yet to be a period in time where growth hasn’t followed recession.

It will come. We just don’t know when.

> You could buy shares for the long-term via The Motley Fool Sharedealing Service.

> See what thousands of other fellow investors are saying about the credit crisis by checking out the Motley Fool’s vibrant discussion boards. Click here to go to the very popular Property - Markets and Trends discussion board.

> Of the companies mentioned in this article, Bruce Jackson has a beneficial interest in HBOS.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

AvensisTom 06 Oct 2008, 11:15am

4. Buy gold coins and stock up on food.

5. Learn to live off the grid as best as you can.

6. Educate yourselves. Learn that it is our monetary system that is flawed. If a critical mass of people can understand our monetary system, then we can educate and replace our leaders to understand and hence better act in our interests in the future.

http://www.silverbearcafe.com/private/moneyasdebt.html
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=7065205277695921912

7. Understand that a fiat money and Keynesian economic system does not serve the interests of the many, but only serves the interests of the few. The global elite.

DerKrobsen 06 Oct 2008, 12:06pm

If the population of USA is 350 million as it says in Wikipedia, the bail out represents $2 billion for every man woman and child.
You can't help feeling that there must have been other solutions (you could repay every toxic mortgage in the country and some) and also that a number of people must be rubbing their hands with glee.

Designprof 06 Oct 2008, 1:05pm

DerKrobsen - I reckon the sum is
700 000 000 000/350 000 000 = $2000 per person

LeVenturian 06 Oct 2008, 1:24pm

I'm with you on this Bruce, only problem is that I am having trouble deciding what are quality holdings as even cash generating companies with low gearing need the financial system to work in order to function.

In a strange way, I am minded to put LloydsTSB in with the quality holdings as their, long criticised, strategy of not fully exploiting the strength of their balance sheet would appear to make them most likely to benefit when the recovery in banking shares finally happens. Of course, that always assumes that any holding is not diluted by them being include in a blanket Government capital injection into the banking sector.

There's no Fool like and old Fool
Keep Fooling

John

TMFVertigo 06 Oct 2008, 1:39pm

DerKrobsen, your name klingt Deutsch? A US billion is 'Milliarden' in German. Hence Designprof's figure is correct.

Neil

supasap 06 Oct 2008, 3:32pm

hi what is fiat money (I am familiar with Keynes and most economic concepts) but fiat money....

AvensisTom 06 Oct 2008, 5:34pm

supasap .. refer to the links I posted, and you shall learn ;)

gordonbanks42 07 Oct 2008, 10:59am

Supasap: Remember "Fiat Lux"? (Let there be light). The "fiat" in "fiat money" is the same "fiat" - in this case "let there be money". Refers to the fact that money these days is created by an act of authority - the central bank says "this is money" and by George, so it is.
In the very old days coins used to be made of precious metal. They were worth what they were worth because what they were made of had that much value.
Then someone decided to circulate less valuable metal or paper tokens instead of the coins, but keep the corresponding amount (and by implication, value) of gold (or silver, or whatever) in a vault somewhere. The paper token is just an IOU representing the gold in the vault. Having the same amount of gold in the vault as you have paper tokens in circulation is called "being on the gold standard".
Then someone decided that they would just create more paper tokens than they had gold in the vault. This is called "coming off the Gold standard". At this point, you have to think real hard about what that one of those paper tokens is worth and how you would value it ...
The supposed advantage of "fiat money" is that the amount of money in circulation does not depend on physical constraints like "how much Gold is there on Earth and how quickly can we mine it all". But that is exactly its disadvantage as well - money can be created very quickly and easily and beyond a certain point it seems to have value but doesn't.

gartons 07 Oct 2008, 11:26am

Perhaps the government could come up with a "Customer Rescue Action Plan" to allay people's fears about bank's going bust, then we would all be in the CRAP.
I am suggesting this as a suitable acronym for the current situation and not being vulgar!

supasap 07 Oct 2008, 3:16pm

Gordonbanks - thanks I had looked on wikipedia and grasped the meaning of fiat money..... I think the common parlance is "paper money" and i recall Maggie restricting its supply in the early 1980's according to some formulas eg M3 etc... but I thought inflation was under control (compared with previous decades) so there would be less pressure on UK government to print money...... on another note though I still find it difficult to get my head around the relationship between the finance world and the real world of wealth creation... for people with real skills and value and I am talking about a pyramid here with brickies plumbers dentists doctors and vegetable growers on top and bankers and speculators and hedge fund managers on the bottom, if the banking system is frozen for years then another currency will step in and facilitate the exchange of goods and services - this is currently cash in hand in black market but equally could be IOUs in a localised market or gold sovereigns .... as long as the currency has legitimacy it would work and it would be those that add true value that would survive... ps just to be clear I work firmly in the non value adding sector ie just making sure my company is more competitive than others in same sector rather than developing the sector itself, reasonably well paid but in the black market my skills are relatively worthless

lubblydubbly 07 Oct 2008, 5:32pm

@AvensisTom

Interesting post :)

I watched the film (well till about halfway through until it just became an advert, the very thing they were so against, for 'the venus project')

I fully support their views on our flawed money system and how it is right that people should know about it and how the federal reserve in the US, and the likes around the world, effectively (as far as I can see as only a layman) generate money out of nothing, and how this only profits the 'global elite'. I can certainly recommend plenty of other viewings / readings on the subject of that and our national debt.

I feel I should warn people about the seemingly irrelevant attacks on religion in this film, lumping it together with the other 'corrupt' mechanisms in our society. Very recently I would have fallen for their very outdated and simplistic view of religion, Christianity in particular, but not now, again I can recommend a lot of reading info on that subject too.

I think the people making this film forget where the very idea of something being 'corrupt', 'indecent' or 'decent', 'immoral' or 'moral', why slavery is a bad thing, etc. etc. comes from.

Sorry for going off topic but it had to be said, it's only 'just' that we should see all the points of view.

Join the conversation

Instructions

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: <b>bold</b>, <i>quoted text</i>. All other tags will be removed from your post.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.